Skip to content
MemBuild
Comparing toolsCircleKajabiSkoolAny platform

Is there a better option than WordPress for a membership platform?

WordPress has a reputation for breaking. Before you pick something else, check what each option can do for paying members.

Updated 7 min read
The short answer

For a simple website, Wix, Squarespace and Webflow are easier to run. For a membership platform that needs member accounts, e-commerce, a CRM connection and an admin dashboard on a server you own, WordPress is still the only option with all five off the shelf. Most bad WordPress experiences come from cheap hosting and too many plugins, and both can be avoided.

The WordPress logo in the middle, ringed by the logos of Wix, Squarespace, Webflow, Ghost, Laravel, Kajabi, Circle, Skool, Memberstack and EmDash.

Why owners look past WordPress

The reasons are good ones, and we hear them often.

Nothing to maintain

No plugin updates, no security patches, no hosting to choose. The company keeps it running.

Easy to edit

You drag a section, change the words and publish. Nobody on your team needs to know what a plugin is.

Polished templates

The site looks good on day one, without paying a designer to make it so.

One bill

Hosting, the editor and support come in one monthly price, instead of a hosting plan plus a list of plugin licences.

A bad WordPress experience

Many owners we talk to had a WordPress site that was slow, broke after an update or got hacked, and don’t want to go through that again.

What Wix, Squarespace and Webflow give up

All three are good website builders. A membership asks more of them: member accounts, subscriptions, and rules for who gets what.

Wix

The Members Area and Pricing Plans let you sell one-time or recurring plans and lock pages to members, on a plan that takes payments. Rules beyond that, like who gets what after a purchase, need Wix’s own Velo code. We found no HighLevel app in the Wix App Market, and the ActiveCampaign app is now only for Wix’s Enterprise accounts. Wix’s help centre says a Wix site can’t be hosted anywhere else.

Squarespace

Member Sites are free to build, and you need a website plan to sell memberships. Squarespace takes a fee on memberships of 7%, 5% or 0%, depending on the plan. Its export is a WordPress file that leaves out store pages, products and video, so moving later means rebuilding much of it.

Webflow

Webflow switched off its own member accounts on 29 January 2026, and the subscriptions built on them went too. It now recommends Memberstack or Outseta for members. Its code export leaves out your CMS content and your store, so what you sell doesn’t come with you.

For a few members-only pages or videos, that can be enough. It gets harder once you want levels, courses, a community, follow-up emails based on what someone did, or your data on your own server.

What a membership platform needs

These are the five things we look for when someone asks us what to build on.

  • Membership: member accounts, levels or plans, and content that opens and locks by what someone paid for
  • E-commerce: subscriptions, one-off products, coupons, failed payments and refunds
  • A CRM connection: tags and contacts that update when someone buys, cancels or finishes a course
  • An admin dashboard: one place to see members, payments and access, and fix them without a developer
  • Your own server: the site, the members and the data live where you choose, so you own it 100% and can move it

The last one matters more than it looks. If a company changes its prices, its fees or its features, a platform on your own server lets you decide what happens next.

The other options, and what each leaves out

Each of these is the right choice for someone. Here’s where each one stands on the five.

Ghost

Open source and easy to host yourself. Members and paid tiers through Stripe are built in, and Ghost takes no cut of what members pay, even on its hosted plans. It connects to CRMs like ActiveCampaign and HubSpot. What it leaves out: courses, a community, and selling anything other than subscriptions and tips. It’s built for paid newsletters.

Fully custom code, like Laravel with Filament

A developer writes the whole platform for you. A common way to do it: Laravel is a free framework, Filament gives it an admin dashboard, and Laravel Cashier handles Stripe subscriptions. Other stacks, like Next.js or Ruby on Rails, work the same way. You own every line and can make it do anything. The cost is that a developer builds every screen members see, every email and every rule, and someone has to look after it for as long as it runs.

Discourse or Moodle

Both are open source and can run on your own server. Discourse is a forum, with Stripe subscriptions built in, but no courses. Moodle is a full course platform for schools and training, with PayPal for course fees in its core. Neither is made to sell memberships, and out of the box each looks like a forum or a school rather than your brand.

Rented platforms: Kajabi, Circle, Skool, Memberstack

Quick to start and nothing to maintain. You pay every month and the company decides the limits. Kajabi starts at $179 a month. Circle Professional is $89 a month on yearly billing, plus a 2% transaction fee. Skool is $9 a month with a 10% fee, or $99 with 2.9%. Memberstack, which adds members to Webflow or another site, starts at $29 a month with a 4% fee. None of them runs on your own server, and going by their help pages, what you can take with you when you leave is mostly your member list.

EmDash

Cloudflare’s new open-source CMS, released as 1.0 on 28 September 2026 and built on Astro. It runs on Cloudflare or on your own Node.js server. For a membership it isn’t ready: its user accounts are for your team, there’s no membership or subscription plugin, and its first e-commerce plugin is still being built by a partner. Plugins from its registry run in a sandbox, which on Cloudflare needs the Workers Paid plan.

Where WordPress goes wrong, and how to avoid it

WordPress is the one option here with all five off the shelf: membership plugins, WooCommerce for selling, connections to the CRMs owners use most, the WordPress dashboard, and hosting wherever you like. The bad history mostly comes from three things.

Cheap hosting

A membership has logged-in members on every page, which shared hosting isn’t made for. The site slows down exactly when members are active, like the morning a course opens.

Too many plugins

A plugin for every small feature, several doing the same job, and some no longer updated. Each one is code that can conflict or let someone in.

Updates on the live site

Clicking Update all on the live site, with members logged in, is how most “it broke after an update” stories start.

None of these is WordPress itself. A membership that stays steady usually has:

  • Managed hosting sized for logged-in members
  • A short list of well-kept plugins, each with one job
  • Updates tested on a copy of the site first
  • Backups you have restored at least once
  • Someone who looks after it, whether that’s you, your team or us

That’s also why it costs more to run than a builder’s single monthly bill. The cost guide below shows what a full year usually adds up to.

When another option fits better

  • You only need a few members-only pages. Stay on Wix or Squarespace if your site is already there.
  • You run a paid newsletter. Ghost does that better and with less to look after.
  • You want to start this month and test the idea. A rented platform like Skool or Circle gets you live fastest. Plan how you’d leave before you grow.
  • Your platform is the product, with rules no plugin covers. Fully custom code, like Laravel with Filament, may be worth its cost.
  • You run formal training with grading. Moodle was made for that.

If you want members, selling, a CRM, a dashboard and a site you own, all together, WordPress is still where we’d build it.

Questions owners ask

Can I run a membership on Wix or Squarespace?

A simple one, yes. Wix has a Members Area with paid plans, and Squarespace has Member Sites with a fee of up to 7% on memberships, depending on your plan. They work best when members pay for access to pages or videos and you don’t need much more. Both keep your site on their own servers.

Does Webflow still have memberships?

No. Webflow switched off User Accounts, first called Memberships, on 29 January 2026, and the subscriptions that depended on it went too. Webflow now points people to Memberstack or Outseta, which add member accounts to your site for a monthly fee.

Is Ghost a good choice for a membership?

For paid newsletters and articles, yes. It’s open source, you can host it yourself, and Ghost takes no cut of what members pay, even on its hosted plans. It has no courses, no community and no way to sell one-off products other than tips, so it fits a publication better than a program.

Is EmDash ready for a membership site?

Not yet. EmDash, the CMS Cloudflare released as 1.0 in September 2026, has no membership or subscription plugin, and its first e-commerce plugin is still being built by a partner. It’s worth watching, and a request for member accounts is open on its GitHub.

Wasn’t WordPress the reason my last site kept breaking?

Usually it was the setup around it. The pattern we see most is cheap shared hosting, a long list of plugins that overlap, and updates done straight on the live site. Good hosting, fewer plugins and testing updates on a copy first fix most of that.

Two ways to start.

Done for you

Tell us about your platform.

Three quick questions, and I’ll reply within a working day with what I’d do. Sometimes that’s “you don’t need us”, and that’s fine too.

the form is right here
Do it yourself

Start with our free plugin.

The free community plugin gives you a feed, courses, chats and events on your own WordPress site.

MemBuild mascot standing beside the form and pointing at it.
Danica Louwe
Tell us about your platform
1. What is your membership running on?
a reply within a working day